|
|
What's the Best HDTV Antenna ? The one that works !
√ Best HDTV Antenna √ Do I need an HDTV antenna?
√ Indoor TV Antennas √ Outdoor TV Antennas √ Digital Tuners
√ UHF Antenna or VHF/UHF antenna?
Important Update to this page!
If you read nothing else on this page read this section.
Selecting the best TV antenna for digital/HDTV.
I wrote the page below "Best HDTV Antenna" in early 2007 about 2 years prior to the analog shutdown. Many have said, it's the best page on the Internet pertaining to the subject. I warned beware of all the new tiny antennas that are flooding the market they won't perform well on the VHF frequency coming after the digital transition is complete. At the time most digital TV signals were broadcasting on the UHF signal band and unethical retailers were taking advantage of the consumer and selling what the consumer wanted a small tiny antenna. UHF antennas can be much smaller then VHF/UHF antennas so they left the VHF portion of the antenna out of the design.
The biggest problem in post digital transition is the reception of VHF digital channels. If you want to see for yourself just search google using the term "vhf digital reception problems"
Unfortunately many manufacturers and retailers are continuing to do this.
Below is a a section from this page "Best HDTV Antenna" called "Buyer Beware". I copied it and brought to the top of the page so you don't miss it. The information is as true today as it was in 2007.
___________________________________________________________
Buyer Beware!
According to the FCC when the digital transition is all said and done there will be 1324 full powered TV stations broadcasting on the UHF frequency band channels 14 through 51. 450 stations will broadcasting on the high band VHF frequencies channels 7-13 and only 37 stations using the low band VHF channels 2-6. Most TV markets in the US will have at least 1 TV station broadcasting on VHF many areas will have 2 or 3 VHF channels. In most case the antenna of choice will need to be VHF and UHF capable.
Don't be fooled! It seems in today's antenna industry any antenna that can receive VHF signals ...no matter how poorly... can be called a VHF/UHF antenna
Fact: Any TV antenna that its width is less then approximately 35" will produce poor high band VHF performance. The narrower the antenna becomes the worse the VHF performance will be. A simple rule of thumb is this. The width of the antenna determines the channel frequency (number) it will receive and the length will generally improve performance on those frequencies.
_____________________________________________________________________
The smallest antenna on the market today that provides strong uniform reception across the entire high band VHF and UHF frequencies is the EZ HD at 35.16 inches long and 34.43 inches wide. As the designer I'm proud to say it has become one of the best selling antennas in America.
If you're in one of the select few locations in the U.S. that does have all UHF signals then there's no need for a VHF/UHF antenna.
Listed below are the Cities where all signals are all UHF. If a location does not appear on the list you need A VHF/UHF TV antenna.
| Huntsville, AL. |
Fort Wayne, IN. |
South Bend, IN. |
Saint Louis, MO. |
| Omaha, NE. |
Buffalo, NY. |
Syracuse, NY.
|
Dayton, OH. |
If all of your TV signals come from any of the Cities listed above you can use an antenna design for UHF reception only.
Bottom line, don't get stuck with a UHF antenna when you need a VHF/UHF antenna. |
In the past couple of years a flood of new TV antennas have hit the market place, claiming to be HDTV antennas, digital TV antennas Etc... These small compact antennas look high tech in design and are very appealing to the consumer, but the fact is HDTV antennas don't even exist.
1. But do these new little so called HDTV antennas really work?
2. Which TV antenna is best for you?
3. What's really going on with this whole digital transition?
4. What do I have to do to be prepared?
5. Do I need a digital/HDTV to continue to receive my free over the air TV?
FACT: All analog TV signals, the ones we have been using for years to receive over the air TV, will be turned of at midnight February 18th 2009.
|
|
Buyer Beware!
According to the FCC when it's all said and done there will be 1324 full powered TV stations broadcasting on the UHF frequency band channels 14 through 51. 450 stations are broadcasting on the high band VHF frequencies channels 7-13 and only 37 stations using the low band VHF channels 2-6. Most TV markets in the US have at least 1 TV station broadcasting on VHF many areas have 2 or 3 VHF channels. In most case the antenna of choice will need to be VHF and UHF capable.
Don't be fooled!It seems in today's world any antenna that can receive VHF signals "no matter how poorly" can be called a VHF/UHF antenna
Fact: Any TV antenna that its width is less then approximately 35" will produce poor high band VHF performance. The narrower the antenna becomes the worse the VHF performance will be. A simple rule of thumb is this. The width of the antenna determines the channel frequency (number) it will receive and the length will generally improve performance on those frequencies. |
Getting the Best HDTV TV Antenna. |
This is the tricky part, where consumer's have and will make the most mistakes.
VHF channels 2 - 13 UHF channels 14 - 69
FACT: Not all digital/HDTV stations will be broadcast on the UHF frequency band, channels 14 through 69, many will broadcast on the VHF frequency band channels 2 through 13.
Many TV markets across the United States currently have VHF digital/HDTV stations and even more stations will broadcast on the VHF band after the analog shutdown in February of 2009. The VHF broadcast band is channels 2 through 13 and the UHF band is channels 14 through 69.
What is the best HDTV antenna ? is the question most asked by our visitors
If your looking for the best performing digital/HDTV antenna system for the very weakest signal areas then that's simple. The Winegard HD 8200U antenna, along with the Channel Master 7777 preamplifier. This equipment will provide the best possible digital/HDTV reception for weak signal areas. Keep in mind most locations won't need an antenna of this size to get good TV reception.
Most of the new compact antennas claiming to be digital/HDTV antennas are UHF antennasor at least they perform very poorly on VHF and should only be used in areas where the VHF digital/HD signals are very strong and where the UHF signals are reasonably strong. VHF channel signals are lower frequencies and UHF channel frequencies are higher frequencies. The lower the channel number the lower the frequency. The wave length of the VHF band is much longer then the UHF band, the waves are much farther apart, less frequent. To maximize the reception performance of these longer wave length of the VHF channels requires a larger TV antenna, the longer wave lengths of the VHF band go right by compact antennas with very little signal captured.
This is where many of the problems will begin. The consumer goes to their favorite Internet search engine and types in the words Best HDTV Antenna or Digital TV antenna. The search engine does its job and brings up the results of the web pages that use the terms HDTV antenna or digital TV antenna within the page and are relevant to the search you requested. I know and you know, that there is no difference between a TV antenna and an HDTV or digital TV antenna but the search engine doesn't. Ethical retailers who know the difference hesitate to call their antennas HDTV or digital TV antennas, so the search engine ignores them because HDTV or digital TV antenna is not used on their pages frequently, and only brings up those retailers who do use these terms.
FACT: Small compact antennas, no matter what kind, can't perform as well as larger antennas can, especially on the VHF channels "not even close" no matter what marketing hype is used to convince you, the physics of TV reception won't allow for it.
Everyone wants the smallest, most inconspicuous TV antennathey can get. The antenna that's the easiest to install and all TV antenna manufactures and retailers know this. Some retailers take advantage of this by misleading the consumer. Currently about 85% of all digital/HDTV signals are being broadcast on the UHF band across the United States. Remember, UHF antennas can be much smaller and still perform reasonable well on the UHF band because of the shorter wave length of UHF. With this in mind some manufactured simply designed small UHF antennas, gave them a futuristic looking design, called them HDTV antennas or digital TV antennas, added some well written marketing hype and put them on the market. Now we all know these manufactures won't have any trouble finding retailers to carry and market these so called digital/HD TV antennas as long as there's a buck to be made.
Don't get me wrong, there are some locations where a small compact TV antennawill provide good quality digital/HDTV reception. You better make sure you are in one of those areas, here's why. Unlike our departing analog TV reception, where the viewer could watch TV even when the TV antenna wasn't producing the best possible picture, HDTV/digital reception is different. In the past you could purchase a TV antenna for analog TV reception, install it and if some of the pictures were snowy because you bought the wrong antenna, you could say good enough, it's better then what we had. HDTV/digital reception requires that you get the TV signals strong enough so the digital tuner can lock onto it. In other words, there's no such thing is a snowy or poor picture when you are using a HD/digital tuner for your reception. You either get a picture perfect picture or you get nothing at all.There is a small area of signal strength where the picture will be there for a moment disappear and come back again, very annoying. The new term for this interruption in the picture and sound is called pixellation.
Pixellation occurs when the TV signal is not strong enoughor some kind of interference is present. As you probably know, reception conditions vary from good to poor in accordance with atmosphere conditions. A TV antenna that can work well in good reception conditions may cause the TV picture to pixellate or not come in at all during poor reception conditions. It's very important that you choose a TV antenna that can produce a strong signal even during times of poor reception conditions.
Indoor antennasare much more susceptible to pixellation and complete loss of signal then outdoor antennas. Smaller, compact designed antennas are much more susceptible then larger antennas. When I recommend a TV antenna for one of our visitors, I make certain it is capable of providing quality reception even during poor reception conditions. If an error is to be made, I make sure it's because I recommended an antenna that's a little to large/powerful versus one that's too small. No one has ever contacted me and said, "Denny I get great reception from the antenna you recommended but I'm really upset, I think it's a little to big and powerful", it doesn't happen. |
How to Choose the Best HDTV Antenna. |
Choosing the proper TV antenna can be time consuming, confusing and frustrating for some. If you would like me to provide you with a recommendation using TV reception data gathered from your particular location. Click-on the following link Get My TV Antenna Recommendation
The first thing you need to know is what channels are available in your area. You can find this out by visiting the Consumers Electronics Association site called antennaweb. This will require that you submit you street address and zip code. This site is consumer friendly and will provide a station listing for your area, the direction of the TV transmitting towers, the channel number of each channel available. At the top of this chart you can choose to display all channels, analog channels only, or digital channels only. The actual channel number of the stations digital broadcast can be found on the right hand side of the page under frequency assignment. Post transition refers to the channel they will broadcast on after the analog shutdown. The color that a particular channel appears in is also important. Stations appearing in Yellow have strong signals at your location, dark Green stations are slightly weaker, light Green weaker yet, followed by Red, Blue, and Violet being the weakest signals.
Remember, VHF channels are 2 through 13 and UHF channels are 14 through 69.
Do you need a VHF/UHF TV antenna or just a UHF TV antenna to receive digital/HD TV reception?
According to Antennaweb, how strong or weak are the signals of each station available in your area?
Generally compact antennas mounted outdoors above your roof line provide good reception on stations listed in the Yellow, light Green and Dark Green. Stations that appear in the Red usually require a larger but small directional TV antenna, Stations that appear in Blue and Violet almost always require a large directional TV antenna to insure consistent quality reception.
Antennaweb.org is Conservative in their channel predictions and may no display all of the channels available in your area.
Remember, compact antennas perform poorly on the VHF band, These lower band VHF channels must appear in the Yellow color on antennaweb or at minimum dark Green, and then dark Green is a risk.
FACT:Just because someone claims a compact modern looking TV antenna is an HDTV antenna or a Digital TV antenna doesn't mean it works any better then any other TV antenna for digital/HD reception. As a matter of fact, the best performing antennas available are still the directional style TV antennas and probably always will be. |
Do I Need an HDTV to get Over the Air Digital Reception with a TV Antenna ? |
Fact: You don't need a HDTV to get over the air digital reception after the analog shutdown in February 2009
Contrary to what some would have you believe, you don't need an HDTV to get digital signalswith a TV antenna. High Definition TV is a format, it provides somewhat of a more vivid picture then standard definition pictures and it's wider in size, but that's it. What really determines whether you can receive over the air digital signals with a TV antenna is the TV tuner itself. If you walk into an appliance store and tell the salesperson you want to buy a new TV, most sales people will lead you directly to the more expensive HDTV's. They may even tell you that HDTV's are the only way to get TV reception with an TV antenna after February 2009, they couldn't be more wrong. Although HDTV's are nice, the fact that they are HDTV's has nothing to do with receiving over the air digital TV signals. More then likely setting off to the side in the showroom are digital TV's - DTV's. These TV's are the same shape and size as analog TV's but they have a built-in digital tuner DTV's are designed to receive over the air digital broadcast, the same broadcast the HDTV can receive. Best of all the price for a DTV is about the same as an analog TV. The picture quality of a DTV will be better then analog reception but not as good as an HDTV set.
The second way you can receive over the air digital TV with a TV antenna is with a digital set top tuner. These tuners receives over the air digital signals and convert them to an analog signal, one that your current analog TV can receive.
If you want an HDTV that's great, but don't let anyone tell you that you have to have one to get over the air digital TV with a TV antenna, it's simply not true. |
HDTV Antenna or Digital TV Antenna Summary |
FACT: All analog TV signals, the ones we have been using for years to receive over the air TV, will be turned off at midnight February 18th 2009.
FACT: Not all digital/HDTV stations will be broadcast on the UHF frequency band, channels 14 through 69, many will broadcast on the VHF frequency band channels 2 through 13.
FACT: Small compact antennas, no matter what kind, can't perform as well as larger antennas, especially on the VHF channels "not even close" no matter what marketing hype is used to convince you, the physics of TV reception won't allow for it.
FACT: Just because someone claims a compact modern looking TV antenna is an HDTV antenna or a Digital TV antenna doesn't mean it works any better then any other TV antenna for digital/HD reception. As a matter of fact, the best performing antennas available are still the large directional style TV antennas and probably always will be.
FACT: You don't need an HDTV to receive free over the air TV after the analog shutdown in 2009.A TV with a built-in digital tuner (DTV) or a digital set top tuner can be used to receive TV after the shutdown,
Choose your antenna carefully, be sure to choose one that can provide quality digital/HDTV reception even during poor reception conditions. A TV antenna that's a little to large/powerful is always better then one that is too small/weak.
If your current TV antenna gets good analog TV reception then it's very likely that the same antenna will provide good digital/HD reception.
Purchase a TV by February 17th 2009 with a built-in digital tuner. It doesn't matter if it's an HDTV or a standard digital TV (DTV) as long as it has a digital tuner, or purchase a set top digital tuner for your current analog TV.
Don't wait until the last minute, the analog shutdown is coming and if you depend on a TV antenna for reception, you could be watching a blank screen on February 18th 2009.
If you have any questions pertaining to over the air TV reception using a TV antenna please don't hesitate to contact me at Mail:TV Antenna Source
|
Best HDTV Antenna or Digital TV Antenna The antenna chart below lists cities that have all UHF digital broadcasts. If none is listed below the State there are no all UHF (14-69) locations within that State. If a city is listed below the State a UHF antenna may be used for reception from the TV stations located in that city. |
Alabama Huntsville TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF Alaska None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Arizona None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Arkansas None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF
California None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Colorado None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Connecticut None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Delaware None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF District of Columbia None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Florida None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Orlando - NBC must come from Daytona Beach on VHF 11 Georgia None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Hawaii None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Idaho None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Illinois None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Indiana Fort Wayne TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF South Bend TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF Note: ABC is low power, a high gain outdoor antenna will be required, unless the TV antenna location is very near to the transmitting tower. Iowa None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF |
Kansas None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHFKentucky None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Louisiana None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Maine None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Maryland None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Massachusetts None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Michigan None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Minneapolis None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Mississippi None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Missouri St. Louis TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF
Montana None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF
Nebraska Omaha TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF Nevada None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF New Hampshire None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF New Jersey None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF New Mexico None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF New York Buffalo TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF Syracuse TV Antenna digital-HDTV -UHF North Carolina None TV Antenna digital-HDTV -VHF/UHF |
North Dakota None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Ohio Dayton TV Antenna digital-HDTV-UHF Oklahoma None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Oregon None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Pennsylvania None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Rhode Island None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF South Carolina None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF South Dakota None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Tennessee None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Texas None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Utah None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Vermont None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Virginia None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Washington None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF West Virginia None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Wisconsin None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF Wyoming None TV Antenna digital-HDTV- VHF/UHF |
Useful Resources Pertaining to Digital/HDTV TV Antenna Reception |
|
|
|